Monday, January 11, 2010

Television = Emotional Porn?

Happy Monday morning to you all.

I was just wondering this morning, why has the television become such a success, available in 98% of American homes, watched for over three hours a day by the average American, eventually eating up almost nine years of our lives? What is it about tv that has so captivated our imaginations?

Here are the top five reasons I think we love the idiot box:

5) We Just Can't Look Away - yes, whether it's the excess and ensuing conflict of Housewives, or someone eating a bowl of cereal on Big Brother, or the 130 pound tumor with teeth and hair and a partially formed ear, sometimes we just can't look away.

4) Knowledge - some folks just like knowing stuff. I think most of us do. So whether it's in order to feel informed (World News) or smart (Jeopardy) or the opposite of naive (20/20), the television feeds this basic desire in us to be in the know.

3) Entertainment - let's face it, most of us spend our lives in a cubicle, staring at a screen. By the end of a long day of emails and meetings and work, we want something different. We want our emotions to be stirred. We want to laugh or cry or feel something, anything, and the deeper the better. Anger, horror, disgust, joy . . . these things awaken in us when we watch television in a way that seems not to happen very often in our normally pedestrian lives.

2) Comraderie - how many shows now have us choosing sides, rooting for someone, taking a team on as our own and then following the result? Survivor, American Idol, Biggest Loser, every single sports league, all those makeover shows? We trash talk other people's favorites if they are not ours. There is something in all of us that wants to choose a side, and win along with them. Example - I recently trash-talked an Eagles fan, mentioning "our 6 Super Bowl rings." What? Our rings? Last time I checked, I don't have a single Super Bowl ring.

And the number one reason I think most people watch television . . .

1) Anesthetic - this may sound like the complete opposite of #3, but hear me out. I think a lot of folks watch television because real life can be so messy and tiring and painful, and at the end of a long day, surrounded by our troubles, sometimes the easiest thing to do is let an outside source entertain us and help us forget about what's going on. Which would you rather do, spend time working on a messy relationship or watch a two-hour program that helps you forget about it and then go to bed? Spend a few hours talking to your spouse when you know things aren't going so well, or safely, without communicating, watch a bunch of relational freaks on tv that make your marriage feel not-so-bad? Engage your teenage kids and find out about all the crap they're involved in, all the tough stuff they're facing, or watch television together and feel like a family? Work out for months so you're in shape enough to compete in a local sports league, or just sit around and let the NFL stimulate your need for competition (ouch, that one hit close to home)?

In some ways, I think television satisfies our need for emotional stimulus the same way many people use pornography to stimulate their sexual desires. Both allow us to escape real life and experience something we want to experience from a safe distance, in a predictable way, and all in a medium over which we have complete control and can turn off whenever we want. The alternative takes too much effort or requires a level of vulnerability we are not prepared to encounter.

Hey, I don't know, maybe I'm completely off base. What do you think are the real reaons we watch television? Having a good laugh? Excellent script-writing? Engaging television shows? Something more innocent than having a base human desire fulfilled?

3 comments:

  1. for me, it's the wonderful feeling of sitting down and NO THING NEEDING ME....just disconnecting from the things around me, (not people, THINGS)....i enjoy looking into other people's lives, (fact or fiction) and forgetting for an hour or two the load of laundry in the dryer waiting for me, the dirty kitchen floor that should be wiped because my daughter is starting to crawl and the boys' clothing drawer that still has shorts in it from last Summer!!! (oh, and eating ice cream without any, shall we call them, beggers)!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. yeah, for me i can think of 3 main reasons:

    1 - to escape. my brain is churning all day long. sometimes it's nice to use a different part of it.

    2 - to bond. my kids and i do lots of things to bond. read books, play games, eat together, take trips, etc. one of those things we do together is watch tv and movies. same goes with erica and i. it's fun to laugh, cry, and be on the edge of your seat if you're experiencing it with someone else.

    3 - to be entertained. this is the biggest reason. whether its sports, information, or compelling stories. it's an enjoyable exercise. we are wired to process things through story, and the great ones (like LOST) move the head and the heart.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Why I watch TV is not all that different than why I read or even drink alcohol. Do I choose a biography, a play, a short story, poetry, a fluffy beach read or a philosophical materpiece. What topic? What time period? Who do I read? Ibsen, Shakespeare or Dickenson? Do I select a glass of wine (or two?), a vodka tonic or a girly cosmo? Eh-depends on the mood.

    Reading seems less passive, which is why from an intellectual standpoint I prefer reading over TV and both over regular alcohol use. Though mixing alcohol use with reading or watching tv can be an attractive combo.

    Am I watching tv, reading or drinking to avoid interacting with someone? to interact with someone? to explore my thoughts? to avoid my thoughts? am i recreating (and if so, how much recreating is ok?), am i trying to find a commonality with someone-to connect? trying to know myself in relation to something i am reading or watching? am i trying to understand others, to gain knowledge? Ponder, ponder.

    The awareness of the whys behind our choosing one activity over another is key. I like that you are exploring the motivation.

    So when I sit down next to watch TV, I will ask myself why why why why why?

    ReplyDelete